2026 Rankings

Best Banks in Ohio

50 banks in Ohio ranked by our TFS Financial Health Grade. Scores based on capital adequacy, asset quality, earnings, and consumer protection data.

Rank	Institution	City	Assets	Score	Grade
1	The Bank of Magnolia Company	Magnolia	$105.3M	82.5	B-
2	The First Central National Bank of St. Paris	St. Paris	$98.2M	80.8	B-
3	Signature Bank, National Association	Toledo	$1.3B	80.7	B-
4	First Financial Bank	Cincinnati	$21.0B	79.0	C+
5	First Federal Community Bank, National Association	Dover	$890.2M	78.8	C+
6	Civista Bank	Sandusky	$4.3B	78.6	C+
7	The Huntington National Bank	Columbus	$224.0B	78.4	C+
8	The Peoples Bank Co.	Coldwater	$831.0M	78.2	C+
9	The Settlers Bank	Marietta	$136.9M	78.2	C+
10	The First National Bank of Blanchester	Blanchester	$78.7M	78.2	C+
11	The Park National Bank	Newark	$9.7B	77.8	C+
12	Buckeye Community Bank	Elyria	$247.6M	77.8	C+
13	The Commercial and Savings Bank of Millersburg, Ohio	Millersburg	$1.3B	77.5	C+
14	The Community Bank	Zanesville	$690.6M	77.5	C+
15	RiverHills Bank	Milford	$343.6M	77.2	C+
16	Portage Community Bank	Ravenna	$533.4M	76.8	C
17	The First National Bank of Sycamore	Sycamore	$233.0M	76.8	C
18	THE HOME LOAN SAVINGS BANK	Coshocton	$376.0M	76.8	C
19	Minster Bank	Minster	$802.2M	76.7	C
20	First Federal Savings and Loan Association	Delta	$242.2M	76.1	C
21	The Killbuck Savings Bank Company	Killbuck	$914.5M	76.0	C
22	KeyBank National Association	Cleveland	$181.7B	75.8	C
23	The North Side Bank and Trust Company	Cincinnati	$1.2B	75.7	C
24	Fidelity Federal Savings and Loan Association of Delaware	Delaware	$131.0M	75.3	C
25	The Richwood Banking Company	Richwood	$1.2B	75.2	C
26	The Croghan Colonial Bank	Fremont	$1.3B	75.2	C
27	The Baltic State Bank	Baltic	$122.0M	75.1	C
28	Fifth Third Bank, National Association	Cincinnati	$213.7B	75.1	C
29	The Union Bank Company	Columbus Grove	$1.2B	75.1	C
30	Unified Bank	Martins Ferry	$851.7M	75.0	C
31	Main Street Bank Corp.	Wooster	$1.5B	74.5	C
32	Mercer Savings Bank	Celina	$174.4M	74.0	C
33	The State Bank and Trust Company	Defiance	$1.5B	74.0	C
34	Citizens Federal Savings and Loan Association	Bellefontaine	$184.6M	73.9	C
35	The Fort Jennings State Bank	Fort Jennings	$274.2M	73.8	C
36	Sutton Bank	Attica	$1.6B	73.8	C
37	Woodsfield Savings Bank	Woodsfield	$115.0M	73.7	C
38	Peoples State Bank	New Lexington	$279.9M	73.6	C
39	First State Bank	Winchester	$1.2B	73.6	C
40	SSB Community Bank	Strasburg	$282.5M	73.5	C
41	United Midwest Savings Bank, National Association	Degraff	$506.7M	73.3	C
42	NATIONAL COOPERATIVE BANK, N.A.	Hillsboro	$4.1B	73.3	C
43	Greenville National Bank	Greenville	$623.5M	73.1	C
44	CFBank, National Association	Columbus	$2.1B	72.9	C-
45	The Cincinnatus Savings & Loan Co.	Cincinnati	$184.4M	72.7	C-
46	Mechanics Bank	Mansfield	$872.5M	72.5	C-
47	Farmers & Merchants Bank	Miamisburg	$354.8M	72.4	C-
48	Peoples Bank	Marietta	$9.6B	72.4	C-
49	The Apple Creek Banking Company	Apple Creek	$260.1M	72.2	C-
50	Bank419	Metamora	$101.2M	72.2	C-

Rankings based on TFS Financial Health Grades, calculated from FDIC quarterly financial data. Scores reflect capital adequacy, asset quality, earnings, liquidity, growth, and consumer protection metrics.Learn about our methodology

All banks in Ohio →All rankings →