2026 Rankings

Best Banks in New Jersey

50 banks in New Jersey ranked by our TFS Financial Health Grade. Scores based on capital adequacy, asset quality, earnings, and consumer protection data.

Rank	Institution	City	Assets	Score	Grade
1	Amboy Bank	Old Bridge	$2.8B	82.8	B-
2	New Millennium Bank	Fort Lee	$953.0M	81.3	B-
3	Provident Bank	Jersey City	$24.9B	78.8	C+
4	Hana Bank USA, National Association	Fort Lee	$799.7M	78.5	C+
5	Monroe Savings Bank	Williamstown	$114.5M	77.5	C+
6	Unity Bank	Clinton	$3.0B	77.1	C+
7	1st Colonial Community Bank	Collingswood	$881.8M	76.3	C
8	Magyar Bank	New Brunswick	$1.0B	76.0	C
9	Lusitania Savings Bank	Newark	$403.7M	75.4	C
10	The First National Bank of Elmer	Elmer	$409.4M	75.2	C
11	First Hope Bank, A National Banking Association	Hope	$666.8M	74.2	C
12	Franklin Bank	Pilesgrove	$334.4M	73.8	C
13	Valley National Bank	Passaic	$64.1B	72.7	C-
14	Sumitomo Mitsui Trust Bank (U.S.A.) Limited	Hoboken	$3.8B	72.5	C-
15	First Bank	Hamilton	$4.0B	72.0	C-
16	Crest Savings Bank	Wildwood	$588.9M	70.7	C-
17	Newfield National Bank	Newfield	$891.4M	70.7	C-
18	The Pennsville National Bank	Pennsville	$287.6M	70.3	C-
19	Manasquan Bank	Manasquan	$3.4B	70.2	C-
20	The Bank of Princeton	Princeton	$2.3B	70.1	C-
21	Columbia Bank	Fair Lawn	$11.0B	70.1	C-
22	Millville Savings Bank	Millville	$167.5M	69.7	D+
23	Spencer Savings Bank, SLA	Elmwood Park	$4.0B	69.0	D+
24	Somerset Regal Bank	Bound Brook	$1.1B	69.0	D+
25	Freedom Bank	Maywood	$812.5M	68.9	D+
26	Parke Bank	Sewell	$2.2B	68.8	D+
27	1st Bank of Sea Isle City	Sea Isle City	$300.9M	68.7	D+
28	Blue Foundry Bank	Rutherford	$2.2B	68.0	D+
29	Peapack Private Bank & Trust	Bedminster	$7.5B	68.0	D+
30	OceanFirst Bank, National Association	Toms River	$14.5B	68.0	D+
31	Sturdy Savings Bank	Stone Harbor	$1.1B	67.3	D+
32	First Commerce Bank	Lakewood	$1.8B	65.9	D
33	Kearny Bank	Kearny	$7.6B	64.8	D
34	Haddon Savings Bank	Haddon Heights	$406.6M	64.8	D
35	ConnectOne Bank	Englewood Cliffs	$14.0B	64.2	D
36	The First National Bank of Absecon	Absecon	$197.1M	64.1	D
37	Century Savings Bank	Vineland	$644.6M	63.8	D
38	United Roosevelt Savings Bank	Carteret	$367.9M	63.6	D
39	Ascendia Bank	Glen Rock	$378.1M	63.3	D
40	Cenlar FSB	Ewing	$899.2M	63.1	D
41	Haven Savings Bank	Hoboken	$1.0B	62.3	D-
42	Crown Bank	Elizabeth	$629.0M	61.0	D-
43	Bessemer Trust Company	Woodbridge	$1.9B	60.8	D-
44	Schuyler Savings Bank	Kearny	$147.4M	60.3	D-
45	GSL Savings Bank	Guttenberg	$149.1M	57.8	F
46	Bogota Savings Bank	Teaneck	$902.5M	55.7	F
47	Union County Savings Bank	Elizabeth	$1.5B	55.0	F
48	Cross River Bank	Fort Lee	$8.1B	54.5	F
49	Five Rivers Bank	Paramus	$34.2M	53.8	F
50	BCB Community Bank	Bayonne	$3.3B	46.8	F

Rankings based on TFS Financial Health Grades, calculated from FDIC quarterly financial data. Scores reflect capital adequacy, asset quality, earnings, liquidity, growth, and consumer protection metrics.Learn about our methodology

All banks in New Jersey →All rankings →